Here is my take why Google Ads for products and services with sales cycles > 90 days is hard. So we are not talking about the high-volume e-commerce advertiser with thousands of conversions a month and a purchase value known at checkout. We also not talking about B2B SaaS with product-led growth (PLG) motions. If you run paid search for a B2B SaaS company with a four-figure ACV, a three-month sales cycle (MLG or SLG) and 30 demos a month, its different. And yet every piece of advice the platform gives you, from the Recommendations tab to the Optimization Score to the quarterly call from your Account Manager, is totally indifferent to that,

This article is about that mismatch. It is not a complaint that automation exists. Smart Bidding, Performance Max and AI Max can work, and in the right conditions they do. I bringing awareness to the fact that that Google has no settings that would let a low-volume, long-cycle advertiser make the automation work, replaced them with a black box, and then built an advisory layer on top of that box which is measured on how much more you spend rather than on whether you grow.

I have spent days on Reddit (r/PPC, r/googleads, r/SaaS) over the years …and: it’s a recurring theme.

Why is the Recommendations tab a sales funnel with a progress bar?

Open any B2B SaaS Google Ads account and the Recommendations tab will tell you roughly the same five things: raise your budget, switch your keywords to broad match, turn on Search Partners, move to Performance Max, and let Smart Bidding set your targets. Then it will show you an Optimization Score, a percentage that goes up only when you do those things, and that has nothing to do with whether your pipeline grew.

The score was never a performance metric. One Google Ads consultant describes a campaign delivering excellent results that carries a 13.8% optimization score. Practical Ecommerce's long-running PPC columnist puts it plainly: implementing recommendations raises the score but, in her experience, not actual performance. A Search Engine Land contributor summed up the practitioner consensus after Google silently rewrote an already-applied recommendation to swap exact and phrase keywords for broad match: most advertisers saw the system as more aggravating than helpful.

What incentives drive Google's recommendations?

What makes the Recommendations tab different from, say, a lint warning in your IDE is that Google tied its own partner ecosystem to it. From February 2022, agencies needed a 70% optimization score across all managed accounts to keep the Google Partner badge. Google later allowed dismissals to count toward the score after agencies revolted, but the signal was sent: the agencies who manage most of the world's mid-market ad spend are graded on how closely they follow Google's suggestions. Nils Rooijmans, a Google Ads scripts specialist, concluded that the best agencies don't wear a Google badge for exactly this reason.

The recommendations themselves are also engineered to spend more. Google's own API documentation for the "Use broad match keyword" recommendation includes a field called required_campaign_budget_amount_micros, described as the budget recommended to avoid becoming budget constrained after applying the recommendation. In other words, the broad-match recommendation ships with its own budget increase. There are separate recommendation types for raising budgets on campaigns that are limited now, campaigns forecast to be limited later, campaigns where ROI is "predicted" to rise with more budget, and campaigns ahead of a seasonal event. There is no recommendation type for "you are overspending on queries that never close."

What is auto-apply, and why does it bite?

In late 2020 agencies discovered Google was auto-applying recommendations inside client accounts through a pilot most of them didn't know they were enrolled in. Search Engine Land reported that the changes did not show in Google Ads change history logs. Google formalised auto-apply in April 2021 as an opt-in with 17 recommendation types, and promised it would not raise budgets. Agencies reported seeing budgets adjusted anyway through auto-applied changes. In 2023 Google changed the definition of the "remove redundant keywords" recommendation to collapse match types into broad, and advertisers who had opted in to the old version stayed opted in to the new one. This year, Google Ads experiments started auto-applying "favorable" results by default for new eligible tests.

The cottage industry this created tells you how practitioners feel about it: there are now paid and free Google Ads scripts whose only job is to alert you when Google, a rep, or an algorithm changes your account. A Vienna-based lead-gen manager quoted on that page calls it the first script he installs on any account he takes over.

Why this is worse for B2B SaaS specifically

Every one of these recommendations is reasonable for a shop with 2,000 orders a month and an average order value Google can see. Broad match plus Smart Bidding works when the algorithm has thousands of conversions to learn which queries pay. Search Partners is fine when a stray click costs €0.40. Raising the budget is fine when the marginal conversion is a €60 purchase that lands today.

For a B2B SaaS advertiser bidding €10 to €50 per click on "sales management software" against 30 qualified demos a month, each of those recommendations is a way to spend more on traffic the algorithm cannot evaluate. The Recommendations tab has no field for "sales cycle length," "ACV," "qualification rate" or "this lead was a student." It has a field for budget.

Do Google Account Managers work for you — or for Google?

If you spend more than a few thousand euros a month, you have met them. The email arrives from an @google.com address, signed by "Your dedicated Google Ads Account Strategist," asking for 30 minutes to "review opportunities" in your account. If you ignore it, the phone calls start. If you ignore those, a new strategist is assigned and the cycle restarts.

Two things about this relationship are not obvious from the outside.

First, the person is almost never a Google employee. On Google's own support forum, advertisers have documented that these strategists, despite the @google.com address and access to your account, are working for third-party companies such as Infinity Contact, TTEC, Teleperformance and Viafon GmbH contracted by Google. They are outbound sales staff at business process outsourcers, working from a script, measured on bookings and on whether spend goes up after the call. One IT consultancy calls the whole programme the Google Ads account strategist con, with the blunt observation that the rep's one job is to get you to spend more, because that is what their commission is tied to.

Second, the advice is the Recommendations tab, read aloud. New Zealand consultant Sam Frost, who has fielded these calls for clients for years, puts it this way: the advice will sometimes benefit your business but will always benefit Google. The pattern in his write-up matches what everyone else reports: the calls are relentless, arrive at odd hours because the call centre is offshore, and the "consultation" is a walk through the same list you can already see in the account: raise budgets, move to broad match, turn on PMax, remove "restrictive" negative keywords, switch to Maximize Conversions.

The "Consult and Recommend Changes" meeting

The formal version of this is the quarterly or monthly "account review," where the strategist screen-shares a deck built from your account data. Practitioners on Google's forum and in agency write-ups describe the same experience: the rep does not know your product, your ICP, your ACV, or your sales cycle, and has not looked at your search terms report. What they have is a slide showing "missed impression share" and "estimated additional conversions if budget is raised," both of which are projections generated by the same system that produces the Recommendations tab. The r/PPC consensus, from a thread where an agency owner reported spending $25M on Google Ads for clients, is that the test of real advice is whether the inputs go beyond "spend more". The strategist call fails that test by design.

Here is what mine said, verbatim:

"FOR PMAX TO WORK, I WOULD RECOMMEND A €100,000 INVESTMENT OVER THE NEXT 30 DAYS."

Our total monthly Google Ads budget at the time was €200,000. So, without a single piece of evidence, data, or case study on why PMax would work for a B2B SaaS account like ours, I was asked to move 50% of my budget into it. Not a €10,000 test. Ultimately I agreed to a €20,000 test. €20,000 down the drain. Literally.

To be fair to the individuals: some advertisers on the same forum report the occasional strategist who gave useful, non-budget advice. The point is not that the people are bad. It is that the role is structurally incapable of giving B2B SaaS advice, because the person has no visibility into the only numbers that matter (pipeline, win rate, ACV, sales cycles) and every incentive to ignore them. Furthermore can someone explain to my why Google Account Manager can not provide technical assistance? How to setup conversion tracking and integrate with your CRM. Takes another team and weeks to get basic stuff sorted if you are doing this the first time.

Do PMax, AI Max and Maximize Conversions work with 30 conversions a month?

Every automated product Google has shipped since 2021 shares one assumption: there is enough conversion data for a model to learn from. Google's own thresholds make this explicit. Target ROAS needs at least 15 conversions in the past 30 days for Search campaigns, and that is the floor to switch it on, not the level at which it works. Practitioners converge on 30 as the minimum for Target CPA to behave and 50 or more for value bidding to be trustworthy. A B2B SaaS account with 20 to 40 qualified demo requests a month, split across three or four campaigns, is below the line for every strategy Google recommends, in every campaign.

Maximize Conversions: the default that quietly redefines "conversion"

Maximize Conversions is the bid strategy Google steers low-volume lead-gen accounts toward, because it has no hard data threshold. The catch is in the name. It maximizes whatever you told it a conversion is, and in B2B SaaS the thing you can measure on-page (a form fill, a trial signup, a content download) is three to five steps away from the thing that pays. Give the algorithm a form fill and it will find the cheapest form fills on the internet: students, job seekers, competitors, bots, people who typed "desk booking" and wanted to book a desk at a hotel.

The PPC Hero write-up on PMax for lead gen describes the root cause well: Google doesn't know whether that enquiry turned into a qualified lead, whether a meeting happened, or whether it became a sale. So it optimises for submissions, regardless of quality. When your volume is already thin, this is doubly bad: the few conversions the model learns from are disproportionately junk, and the model has no counter-signal.

Performance Max: the "feedback loop of doom"

PMax is the recommendation that appears most insistently in B2B accounts, and it is the one with the worst track record. The Australian B2B agency farsiight, which maintains a live post on the subject, opens with a sentence that should be on the Recommendations tab instead: most B2B companies should not be running Performance Max. Their description of what happens is worth paraphrasing in full, because it is exactly what B2B SaaS teams report:

  • PMax discovers it can get cheap form submissions from Display and Gmail placements.
  • Bots and low-quality traffic fill in forms; Google counts them as conversions.
  • The algorithm concludes Display and Gmail "work" and shifts budget there.
  • Real search traffic is starved; lead quality drops further.
  • The algorithm doubles down. Sales starts ignoring marketing leads.

The structural problems are the same ones every B2B practitioner lists:

  • No control over placements. PMax spends across Search, Display, YouTube, Gmail, Discover and Maps and decides the split itself. For B2B, the non-Search inventory is where lead quality collapses.
  • Audience signals are suggestions, not targeting. You can upload your customer list and layer in-market segments; PMax can still ignore all of it if conversion data points elsewhere. For a company whose buyer is "facility or HR leaders at companies with 200+ hybrid employees," that is disqualifying.
  • Brand cannibalisation. Without explicit brand exclusions PMax absorbs your branded search, reports those conversions as its own, and makes the campaign look profitable. GrowthSpree lists this as one of two failure modes alongside low-intent volume.
  • Reporting is a black box. A Belgian B2B agency notes that even Google admits advertisers experience PMax reporting transparency as a bottleneck.
  • Volume. farsiight's realistic threshold for PMax optimising on SQLs is well above the commonly cited 30 a month. An account producing 10 SQLs a month, in their words, does not have enough signal to optimise reliably.

The market has noticed. Despite years of Google pushing PMax as the default recommendation, Pixis's 2025 benchmarks cited by farsiight show PMax holding only 13 to 18 percent of monthly Google spend, flat or declining in several industries. Advertisers are treating it as a minority allocation, not the primary channel Google's reps describe. However this data is of course a blend, and I would be curious about actual B2B SaaS numbers.

AI Max for Search: better inventory, same problem

AI Max for Search, launched in May 2025 and now the forced successor to Dynamic Search Ads, is the more defensible of the two for B2B because it stays on the Search network. It expands your keywords to conversational and long-tail queries you are not bidding on and rewrites headlines per query. That is a real capability as AI Overviews change how people search.

But it inherits every weakness of broad match in a low-volume account. Agencies testing it for B2B SaaS report that without an extensive negative list and offline conversion data, AI Max can expand to low-quality search terms; one playbook recommends a 1,500-term negative list before switching it on. farsiight describes itself as sceptics who keep testing, with mixed results. The query expansion is only as good as the conversion signal that tells the model which expansions were worth it, and that signal is the thing B2B SaaS cannot supply at volume.

What ties PMax, AI Max and Maximize Conversions together?

In all three cases the product does something defensible for an advertiser with data, and something destructive for an advertiser without it. Google's response to the second group has been to recommend the product harder, not to add the settings (minimum lead-quality gates, placement allowlists, hard audience restrictions, a "wait for qualification before learning" mode) that would let a low-volume account use it safely.

Does value-based bidding work when the deal closes four months after the click?

Google's answer to "Maximize Conversions chases junk" is value-based bidding: assign a value to each conversion, switch to Maximize Conversion Value or Target ROAS, and let the algorithm pursue revenue instead of volume. For e-commerce this is close to free. The purchase value is known at checkout, it arrives seconds after the click, and there are thousands of them. For B2B SaaS, every one of those three conditions fails, and Google has given advertisers almost no settings to compensate.

The time horizon problem

Start with the window. A new Google Ads conversion action defaults to a 30-day click-through window, and the maximum you can set is 90 days. (It is 90, not 60; 60 is one of the presets, and the number that trips people up because assisted conversions are reported at 30, 60 and 90 days regardless of your setting.) Anything that happens more than 90 days after the click is, as far as Google Ads is concerned, not attributable to the ad.

Offline conversion import has its own, harder ceiling. Google states that it retains the GCLID for only 90 days, and offline conversions uploaded more than 90 days after the last click won't be imported. The newer enhanced conversions for leads, which Google now pushes as the preferred setup, is tighter still: uploads more than 63 days after the click are dropped.

Put that against a B2B SaaS sales cycle. For a mid-market deal, 90 to 180 days from first demo request to signature is normal; enterprise is longer. The conversion that actually carries value, closed-won revenue, falls outside the window for a large share of deals, and outside the enhanced-conversions window for most. The only events you can reliably send back are intermediate ones: SQL, opportunity created, maybe proposal sent. You are therefore not doing value-based bidding on revenue. You are doing it on a stage your sales team reached inside roughly two months, with a value you made up.

There is no setting for this. You cannot tell Google Ads "my sales cycle is 150 days, hold judgement." You cannot extend the GCLID retention. You cannot upload a closed-won deal in month five and have it reattach to the click. The lookback is the lookback. Also I must say, that I would love to see how much the algorithm changes when you report back after 1 day, 10 days, or 30 days. An then actually changes your ad placements for the better compared to online conversions (in whatever strategy).

The proxy-value problem

The standard workaround is a value ladder: form fill €50, MQL €200, SQL €800, opportunity €3,000, closed-won the real ARR. Every agency guide recommends it, and it is better than nothing. But look at what it does to the algorithm's training data. Elevarus's guide to value-based bidding for lead gen notes that if every conversion carries the same value, value-based bidding is mathematically identical to count-based bidding; GA Connector calls static values the single most common reason value-based bidding fails in lead gen. So you differentiate values, and now the algorithm is optimising toward your scoring model rather than toward money. If your SQL definition is loose, tROAS will find more loose SQLs. The model does not know the difference, and it will not tell you which signals it used, because the bidding logic is a black box: you see a target and an outcome, never the weights. I have trief similar proxis such as: Enterprise customer = value of 10. Mid-market customer = value of 3. Small customer = value of 1, using CRM employee data to create the segments. Problem is: you need a ton of conversions for the algo to pick up any plausible optimization signals. Good luck trying to detect that among all the signals like seasonality, year end, quarterly end and so on.

The few-high-value-conversions problem

This is the part the "just import offline conversions" advice skips. Even with a flawless CRM integration, a B2B SaaS account produces a value distribution that Smart Bidding is bad at. In a typical month you might have 30 form fills, 20 SQLs, 10 opportunities and 5 closed deals, with one being worth €40,000 compared to the other 4 closing at €3,000 – all in a single campaign. The closed deals are worth more than everything else combined. A model that needs, by Google's own threshold, 15 conversions in 30 days just to be switched on, and by practitioner consensus 50 with reliable values to behave, is being asked to learn from one or two high-value events per month, each of which arrived two to five months after the click it is attributed to.

Optmyzr's write-up of value-based bidding limitations is specific about why this is harder than count bidding: tROAS requires an additional calculation of the conversion's value on top of predicting conversion likelihood, so it needs more data, not less, and it evaluates against the target over a rolling 30-day period. Another guide recommends calculating targets on the median rather than the average, which outliers skew. In B2B SaaS the outliers are the business. One €40k deal lands in a month and tROAS concludes the campaign is wildly profitable, loosens bids, and spends the next six weeks chasing lookalikes of a click that happened in April. The deal slips, nothing lands, and the same strategy decides the campaign is a disaster and throttles it.

The experience of agencies who have done this properly is sobering. One B2B SaaS playbook I found doing some research recommends a progression of Manual CPC until 15 conversions a month, then Max Conversions with a CPA target until 30, then tROAS only after 60-plus days of stable conversion value data, and notes that without enhanced conversions 40 to 60 percent of imported conversions fail to match a click at all, arriving in Google Ads with no value and therefore invisible to bidding. For an account that was marginal on volume to begin with, losing half the signal in transit is the end of the exercise.

What does value-based bidding add up to for B2B SaaS?

The honest summary is that value-based bidding in B2B SaaS is a system with four compounding sources of noise (a 90-day ceiling, a 63-day ceiling for the recommended method, proxy values you invented, and a handful of lumpy real values) feeding a model with no exposed parameters, which Google's documentation describes as working "best" at volumes a B2B SaaS account will never reach. The advice from the Recommendations tab and from the strategist is nonetheless to switch it on, because a value signal, any value signal, makes Smart Bidding spend more confidently.

It is not that Google could not fix this. A configurable GCLID retention of 365 days, a "sales cycle length" input that tells bidding to discount recent cohorts, a value cap or winsorisation setting for outliers, and a diagnostic showing which signals drove bids over the last 30 days would turn value bidding from a trap into a tool for this segment. None of them exist. Everything in the interface pushes toward fewer settings, not more.

What actually works for B2B SaaS paid search

None of this means you should leave Google. Search intent is still the highest-quality demand signal in B2B, and a buyer typing your category into Google is worth paying for. Let’s talk how!